|
Rain welcomed the participants to the Final of the
2002/2003 European Law Moot Court Competition in Luxemburg. The grey skies were
however not enough to demoralize the best teams selected at the regional finals
of the European Law Moot Court in Lisbon, Helsinki, Riga and Bratislava. The
very first day was of an introductory nature: a visit to the European Court of
Justice and Court of First Instance giving us all a very informative insight in
the everyday work and life at the Courts, an experience which cannot be taught
or learned from books. The visits were of course too short as the impatiently
awaited competition was scheduled to begin the day after, on the 7th of March
2003.
Florence Kramer represented the NYU Law School Team in
the Advocate General Competition. Before the ECJ gives its Judgment, the
Advocate General delivers his/her Opinion, the purpose of which being to assist
the Court in reaching its decision. The Opinion is not binding. After
delivering their views, the Advocate General plays no further part in the
proceedings. The next step is for the judges in the Court to reach their
decision.
The moot case was
that of Medex plc v Longevita Ltd. This case was presented by Ms Kramer,
who also, in a role not often that of an AG, defended her Opinion. As biased as
it may sound, we may now say that she managed to do it brilliantly, a fact
later recognized by the judges, who rewarded her with an internship with a
leading Spanish Law firm.
Sadly the NYU Law school team left Luxemburg without the
cup, which was awarded to the UK team from Inner Temple for the general
competition and to the College of Europe - Natolin for the Advocate General
Competition. Nevertheless, the team gained invaluable experience and needless
to say, beautiful memories. We hope too that driven by the success at this our
first participation, the team will inspire some aspirations for future
participants in the European Law Competition. |
|
Members of the NYU European Law Moot Court Team spent the last
week of January in Lisbon, Portugal, competing in a Regional Final of the
European Law Moot Court Competition. The four team members, Jose
Feris, Karin Intermill, Florence Kramer
and Tzvika Nissel, accompanied by their coach, Emile Noel
Fellow Martina Kocjan, competed as one of ten teams for the
opportunity to advance to the All European Finals of The European Law Moot
Court Competition. The NYU team won the competition for the Advocate General
position in the All European Final, thanks to the accomplished argumentation of
Florence Kramer. All four members of the team are
concurrently undertaking LLM degrees during the academic year 2002/2003.
The European Law Moot Court Competition is the second
largest international moot court in the world, and the largest and most
prestigious in Europe. Supported and hosted by Universities all over Europe,
the Competition is widely recognized as one of the most efficient ways to learn
European Law and legal practice in general.
Teams from Universities worldwide prepare submissions
setting out arguments on behalf of both the Applicant and Defendant in the
proceedings before the Court of Justice. The written submissions are sent to a
panel of judges comprising of professors, judges, lawyers or Commission
representatives who, during the Regional final, act as Judges of the Court of
Justice in the Competition.
On the basis of their written submissions, only the top
40 teams and invited to attend a Regional Final, which represents the second
stage of the Competition. The location of each of the four Regional finals,
which are held in February each year, varies from year to year. In 2003, they
are taking place in Lisbon (Portugal), Helsinki (Finland), Riga (Latvia) and
Bratislava (Slovakia). Teams are required to present their arguments to a panel
of eight Judges sitting as the Court of Justice. Ten teams are sent to each
Regional, but only one team and one Advocate General or Commission
Representative proceed to the third stage, the All European Final in
Luxembourg.
Doubts as to what a US Law School possibly achieve on a
European Union law competition, were silenced, when some of the participating
teams faced the NYU team as their opponent. Indeed NYU was not the first US Law
school to participate (in the 2000/1 edition The Golden Gate University - San
Francisco hosted a Regional Final), but was by far the most successful.
The All European Final will take place from March 5th to
8th 2003 at the Court of Justice of the European Communities before Judges from
the Court of Justice and Court of First Instance. Doubtlessly, NYU School of
Law could not have hoped for better representation. |